computer etiquette

community forum moderation - how to moderate a swarm of bots?

background on the situation:

A reader writes that they are an online community forum moderator. A new member of the forum has recently posted about one of their new projects, and their posts appear to be written by generative AI. The reader, as moderator, took down a post from this new member, politely explaining to them that the forum prioritizes “human-authored” conversation. The new member protested. Soon after this incident, a bunch of new accounts in the forum appeared, writing in support of the new member. How to moderate a swarm of bots?

some suggestions:

I’m not acquainted with the technical approaches available to help deal with this (filters, plugins, etc.) so if anyone reading this has tips on that front, please do pass them along and I’ll update this post.

So long as this is a private community forum (I'm assuming it is), it's a good time for a confident hand on the delete post action, as well as on the delete member (bot) front.

Before making these moves, it would be helpful to post a short terms of service paragraph about how the forum handles generative AI posts and bots. If there are any inquiries about your policy from this (or any other) community member, it’s helpful to have this kind of working rationale to point to. It's also vital to be open to acting in error, to acknowledge that you might do so, that it's likely you'll make mistakes in implementation. Try to stay flexible with this. People need to understand that we're all in this uninvited mess together, and that we're all just doing our best to move through it.

In your policy, you could write that the forum prioritizes "human-authored" content, something that you can only do your best to identify, and that it does not support bots as members, nor can members have multiple accounts. If a new account has been deleted in error, the person behind it can contact the forum. But you still retain the authority to make decisions based on the information you have and your best efforts and experience. You will moderate posts and members in good faith, and trust that people participating in the forum can understand the limitations on your capacity as a community moderator both to know what is "human-generated", as well as your capacity to follow-up with any kind of human validation process, as this is not sustainable.

Finally, you can also include that this is a constantly evolving situation, and you will continue to adapt your approach as best you can. You can acknowledge that in some cases people may be using generative AI tools to support their participation in written interactions, and that you are always open to finding ways to be inclusive within your community forum.

(Note: These are general suggestions, not legal advice.)